EU

Malaysia and Indonesia Palm Oil Export Ban to the European Union

Segi Enam’s Khor Yu Leng was interviewed by Free Malaysia Today (FMT) on Malaysia’s latest position on plans to ban on palm oil export to the European Union (EU) following the new deforestation regulation. She mentioned that the ban will cause an “unexpected effect” and that many of Malaysia’s palm oil suppliers are still keen to supply to the EU as it is a premium market. She also points out that “Indonesia’s multi-pronged approach shows that it also takes pro-buyer and pro-climate action while voicing concerns from government to government”. Read the full article by FMT here.

On PalmTrack, we also wrote about this. Read it here (subscribers only).

In other related news:

PalmTrack—Sep 2022 Wrap Up

Here is a wrap up of the some of the issues PalmTrack covered in Sep 2022:

  1. Malaysia plantation labour issues seem to be escalating. There is now worrying talk about destination market checks and signs that at-risk suppliers are facing buyer jitters. Indonesia suppliers may gain. This is amidst heightened problems for authorities to deal smoothly with migrant labour recruitment compliant with Indonesia, Bangladesh, and other requirements.

  2. Going by Malaysia’s palm oil production in the last 15 years, it is clear that yield-productivity management is in a major rut, a warning to producers in other countries. The more recent ups-and downs seem to be driven more by the climate cycle of El Niño dry/La Niña wet than anything else, at least at the aggregate level. Read more on PalmTrack.

  3. HCPO or high FFA CPO is the big new trend at palm oil mills. The processing of loose and rejected fruits gives a product with 35-40% FFA that suits HVO and more. But Malaysia’s unfavourable pricing for loose fruit is likely to hinder its supply. Indonesia prices a premium for loose fruits and buyers should see better prospects here. We talked to specialists to find out more.

  4. BOM officially declared a La Niña on 13 Sep 2022. However, the meteorological agency has stated that projections indicate this third dip to be short-lived and is expecting the phenomenon to peter out by early 2023.

  5. The EU Parliament has adopted the proposal on deforestation-free products. The regulation aims to eliminate deforestation in the import supply chain for the EU for several key commodities and products, including palm oil and soy.


Khor Reports’ PalmTrack is an independent research service that tracks palm tanker movements and reports trade of palm products (and shipments, upon request) for selected trade routes. It features a forward-looking market topic and sharp analysis every quarter, e.g. palm biofuels issues & opportunities for Jan–Mar 2022. Subscribe now!

$380.00
Every year
$38.00
Every month

Carbon Tax News: Updates from Singapore, EU, and Malaysia

Last Friday, Singaporean Finance Minister Lawrence Wong announced in his budget speech that the island nation’s carbon tax rate will be increased as part of Singapore’s efforts to reach net-zero emissions by or around 2050. At the moment, the current tax of S$5 per tonne of emissions will continue to be in force until 2023, and will be increased incrementally before reaching a rate of somewhere between S$50–80 per tonne by 2030. This was higher than initial expectations of a carbon tax increase to anywhere between S$10 and S$15 per tonne, with one expert, PwC’s Chris Woo, remarking “if we don’t tax that supply chain, another country will.”

Over at the EU, carbon prices on its emission trading scheme (ETS) have risen beyond expectations over the past year. This has prompted calls for authorities to address design flaws in the ETS, with recommendations from the European Green Party and Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research including reforms aimed at curbing excessive financial speculation. Traders are now reportedly becoming wary following the European Commission agreeing to look into ways to make trading activities more transparent.

From Trading Economics (accessed 21 Feb 2022): “EU carbon permits traded close to €90, down from a record €98.5 reached on February 8th, following news that EU lawmakers were mulling key reforms in the bloc’s carbon market, and higher energy output from non-polluting sources.”

In Malaysia, eyes are now on how national policy and regulators will deal with the Sabah state government’s proposal for the National Conservation Agreement (NCA), a 100-year mega carbon asset concession project in collaboration with Singaporean-based company Hoch Standard Pte Ltd. Social media is alight with the purportedly leaked document of the aforementioned agreement, with interesting comments—including remarks on the statement made by the Sabah Deputy Chief Minister just last week—from investigative website Sarawak Report.

On that note, the Sarawak government has also announced intentions to venture into a carbon credit project, with Mambong assemblyman Dr Jerip Susil revealing that the state may pass a legislation allowing for carbon credits trading to take place this year. In the meantime, the Malaysian government has agreed to the development of a Voluntary Carbon Markets to facilitate international carbon credit transactions.

SCMP: Improved Public Relations a Must in Malaysia's Defence of Palm Oil

Malaysia’s defence of palm oil against the EU continues, with the former’s more recent move being filing an official complaint with the World Trade Organisation (WTO) on grounds that the EU anti-palm oil campaign is in violation of WTO rules. SCMP, however, reports that experts believe Malaysia needs to improve its public relations in order to succeed in its complaint and its defence of palm oil in general. One of the interviewed experts is Segi Enam principal, Khor Yu Leng, who was quoted as below:

Khor Yu Leng, a political economist at Segi Enam Advisors, said the EU’s issues with the use of palm oil – including allegations of labour abuse within the industry, concerns over deforestation and other systemic risks – have threatened its future as a sustainable product.

“These issues need to be addressed with convincing evidence that this is of low incidence and there is an improvement plan,” she said.

“On the supply side, there has been a chronic shortage of labour in Malaysia over the years that has meant less than optimal operations and production,” she said, adding that the problems point to questions over “how the Malaysian authorities can address systemic labour market problems.”

“Flat denials from the authorities regarding deforestation or other oversights and no data transparency is a contrast to how commodity producers are nowadays aiming to charm their customers – the countries we export to,” she said.

“The other thing is to consider whether it serves palm oil‘s interest to be in the limelight too much. Being criticised on social media for poor human rights records is just not a good place to be,” she said, referring to the avalanche of bad publicity Malaysia received when the US slapped bans on the country’s top palm oil plantations.

T&E: Palm-based Biofuels In the EU and #NotInMyTank

In recent news, Transport & Environment (T&E) reported that palm oil is being used more as biodiesel than as food products within the EU. The European-based campaign group explained that the EU is experiencing a rise in vegetable oil use for energy production in the past 10 years, with 2019 being the “all-time high of 4.5 million tonnes in 2019 and that “[i]n contrast, the use of palm oil to make food dropped to an all-time low of 2.8 Mt”. It also provides an interesting map graphic (immediately below) showing palm biodiesel producers across Europe.

Following this, T&E and several other organisations have begun a #NotInMyTank movement on Twitter in attempt to urge European governments to stop its support for food-based biofuels, which includes those from palm and soy origins.

In the Media: The EU, Malaysian Smallholders and Big Data-Informed Sustainability by KHOR Yu Leng

In the Media: The EU, Malaysian Smallholders and Big Data-Informed Sustainability by KHOR Yu Leng

Systems informed by big data can offer compelling evidence for the smallholders. For instance, Malaysia could easily point EU policymakers and buyers to smallholder zones that have been in production (no deforestation) since 2000, 1985, 1970 and so on. For every 300,000ha of smallholder plantations found, buyer could get over one million tonnes of no-deforestation palm oil.